Escape to island paradise in a Sanibel & Captiva rental home

Rent a vacation home or condo just steps from white sand beaches


Trusted Hospitality

Established in 1998, we welcome over 50,000 guests per year to our homes in Orlando and Sanibel & Captiva Islands.


Unbeatable Value

Choose from a variety of homes to meet your needs and budget. Enjoy extras like pool & spa heat and free Wi-Fi.


Quality & Service

Enjoy unmatched service and professional maintenance and cleaning. Our friendly Guest Services Team is available to help.

As seen in

Experience carefree island life at its finest

Kick off your shoes, step into the sand and get away to Sanibel & Captiva Islands. All of our Sanibel & Captiva vacation home rentals are only minutes to beaches, restaurants, shops, wildlife preserves and other attractions. Some of our vacation homes on Captiva Island are even located right on the beach, so you can enjoy spectacular ocean views from your own private bedroom suite.

Explore all there is to do on Sanibel & Captiva Islands from shelling to bike riding, fishing, boating, snorkeling, shopping and more! Visit the popular Doc Ford’s Rum Bar & Grille, stroll through shops along Andy Rosse Lane or discover the rich history of the islands at the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village. Nature lovers can collect shells from Bay or Gulf shelling beaches or spot rare birds in the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge. Enjoy your family’s favorite beach activities or discover new experiences to make lasting memories.

Our affiliations & partners

All Star is proud to be a member of the Sanibel-Captiva Chamber of Commerce. All Star also holds memberships in vacation home industry and travel associations.

Learn more about our affiliations & partners

Luxury vacation home amenities

All Star provides a selection of vacation rentals that accommodate all budgets and groups. Our vacation homes on Sanibel & Captiva Islands offer everything your family needs for an incredible Florida beach vacation. Enjoy features like:


Easy beach access


Ocean views


Private heated pools




Multiple private suites


TVs in every bedroom


Fully equipped kitchens


Washers & dryers

Guest services

Can’t find the extra towels at 3 a.m.? Coordinating a family reunion or meeting in your vacation home? Hosting a birthday celebration in your home’s pool area and need party platters, balloons and pool floats? Whatever your needs, we’re available to help you.

Why choose All Star?

Check-in Ready

Each rental home listed on the All Star site is professionally cleaned and maintained for your enjoyment.

Easy Payments

Once you’ve reserved a home, make payments that fit your budget and schedule. No interest. No fees. No worries.

Free Wi-Fi

Every vacation home rental and condo has FREE Wi-Fi. Stay connected on your favorite devices, or post a vacation selfie.